Product care guide · 2026-05-28

How to Care for Your Handmade Jewelry

Handmade jewelry deserves care that matches the thought that went into making it. This guide covers tarnish prevention, stone-specific care, cleaning methods for different metals, and safe storage practices based on published recommendations from jewelry supply companies and gemological organizations.

Browse handmade jewelry Sell with us

Routine care

Proper care extends the life of handmade jewelry and keeps each piece looking its best. These steps are based on published care recommendations from material suppliers and conservation guidelines.

Put jewelry on last, take it off first

Every wear

Apply lotions, perfumes, sunscreen, and hair products before putting on jewelry. These products contain chemicals that can tarnish metals, dull gemstone surfaces, and degrade certain finishes. At the end of the day, remove jewelry before washing hands, showering, or applying skincare. This single habit prevents more damage than any cleaning routine.

Wipe down after wearing

After each wear

After each wear, gently wipe your jewelry with a soft, dry cloth (microfiber or a dedicated jewelry polishing cloth) to remove body oils, perspiration, and residue. This 30-second habit significantly slows tarnish buildup on silver and keeps gemstones looking their best.

Clean silver with a polishing cloth or mild solution

Monthly, or as tarnish appears

For light tarnish on sterling silver, a jeweler's polishing cloth (impregnated with anti-tarnish compound) is the safest first step. For heavier tarnish, soak in warm water with a few drops of mild dish soap for 5-10 minutes, then gently scrub with a soft toothbrush. Rinse thoroughly and dry completely. Avoid silver dip solutions on pieces with patina (intentional darkening in recessed areas) — the dip removes all oxidation, including the intentional kind.

Clean gold and gold-filled pieces gently

As needed

Soak in warm (not hot) water with a drop of mild dish soap for 10-15 minutes. Use a very soft brush (baby toothbrush) to clean around settings and in crevices. Rinse in clean water and dry with a soft cloth. Gold-filled jewelry should never be cleaned with abrasive compounds or commercial jewelry cleaners designed for solid gold — the abrasives can wear through the gold layer.

Handle gemstones according to their hardness

As needed

Not all stones can be cleaned the same way. Diamonds, sapphires, and rubies (hardness 9-10 on the Mohs scale) tolerate warm soapy water and gentle brushing. Softer stones like opals (5.5-6.5), pearls (2.5-4.5), turquoise (5-6), and emeralds (7.5-8, but often fracture-filled) require only a damp soft cloth — no soaking, no chemicals, no ultrasonic cleaners. When in doubt about a stone, use only a damp cloth.

Storage

How and where you store handmade jewelry matters as much as how you use them. Poor storage is one of the most common causes of preventable damage.

Store each piece separately in individual soft pouches, compartmentalized jewelry boxes, or wrapped in anti-tarnish cloth. Pieces stored touching each other will scratch — harder stones scratch softer ones, and metals scratch each other.
Include anti-tarnish strips or silica gel packets in your jewelry storage to absorb moisture and slow oxidation. Replace strips every 6-12 months.
Keep jewelry away from bathrooms, where humidity accelerates tarnish. A bedroom drawer or closet shelf is better.
Store silver in anti-tarnish bags or wrapped in anti-tarnish cloth. Exposure to air (specifically sulfur compounds in air) is the primary cause of silver tarnish.
For necklaces, hang them or lay them flat to prevent tangling. Tangled chains put stress on links and clasps.
Remove jewelry before swimming (chlorine attacks metals and can loosen stone settings), exercising (sweat plus friction), or sleeping (stress on settings and clasps).

Common mistakes to avoid

Even well-intentioned care can damage handmade items if you use the wrong method. Here are the most common mistakes and what to do instead.

Using toothpaste to clean jewelry

What happens: Toothpaste is abrasive — it contains fine grit designed to polish tooth enamel, which is harder than most metals and many gemstones. It will scratch gold, silver, and soft stones, leaving dull patches and fine scratches that trap dirt.

Instead: Use warm water with a drop of mild dish soap, or a jeweler's polishing cloth. These are gentler and more effective.

Wearing jewelry in the shower, pool, or hot tub

What happens: Chlorine in pools and hot tubs attacks gold alloys (especially lower karats like 10K and 14K), weakening the metal and potentially changing its color. Hot water from showers can loosen adhesive-set stones. Soap residue dulls stones and builds up in settings.

Instead: Remove all jewelry before water activities. Make it a habit to have a designated jewelry dish near the shower or pool area.

Using ultrasonic cleaners on all jewelry

What happens: Ultrasonic cleaners use high-frequency vibration to loosen dirt. While safe for hard, unfractured stones in solid metal settings, they can damage or destroy: pearls, opals, emeralds (which are almost always fracture-filled), turquoise, tanzanite, and any stone with inclusions or surface-reaching fractures. They can also loosen bezel and prong settings.

Instead: Reserve ultrasonic cleaning for diamonds, sapphires, and rubies in sound settings. For everything else, use the warm-soapy-water method.

Storing all jewelry together in one pouch or box

What happens: Metals scratch metals, and harder stones scratch softer ones. A diamond pendant stored loose with silver rings will scratch the silver. Sterling silver chains tangled together will scratch each other and be frustrating to untangle.

Instead: Store each piece separately. Fabric-lined compartmentalized boxes, individual pouches, or even small zip-lock bags with anti-tarnish strips work well.

Simple repairs

Minor wear is normal and often fixable at home. For significant damage, consult the maker or a professional conservator.

Tarnished sterling silver that doesn't respond to a polishing cloth can be cleaned with the aluminum foil method: line a bowl with foil, add hot water and a tablespoon of baking soda, and place the silver in contact with the foil for 2-3 minutes. The electrochemical reaction reverses tarnish without removing any silver metal.
Loose stones should be addressed immediately — continuing to wear a piece with a loose stone risks losing the stone permanently. Many handmade jewelers offer tightening and resetting services for pieces they've made.
Bent prongs on rings can sometimes be gently pressed back with smooth pliers (non-serrated jaws only), but professional repair is safer. Prongs protect the stone — a broken prong means a lost stone.
Stretched or broken chain links can often be repaired by a jeweler or the original maker with matching links and solder. Save any broken pieces to give the repairer.
Replating worn gold-filled or gold-plated pieces is possible but often costs more than the original piece. For sentimental items, it may be worth it. Consult the maker or a local jeweler for options.

Why handmade items are worth the care

They last longer

Handmade items are typically built from higher-quality materials and constructed with more attention to durability than mass-produced equivalents. Proper care lets that quality show over years of use.

They develop character

Many handmade materials — leather, wood, ceramics, metals — develop a patina or subtle changes with use. This aging is a feature of natural materials, not a defect.

They reduce waste

A well-maintained handmade piece that lasts a decade replaces multiple disposable alternatives. Caring for what you own is one of the simplest sustainability choices you can make.

They can be repaired

Unlike factory items designed for disposal, most handmade pieces can be repaired by the original maker or a skilled artisan. The maker often knows exactly how to fix their own work.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my sterling silver tarnish so quickly?

Sterling silver tarnishes when it reacts with sulfur compounds in the air, in foods (eggs, onions), and in some personal care products. The rate depends on your environment: high humidity, proximity to the ocean (salt air), pollution, and even your individual body chemistry affect tarnish speed. Some people's skin chemistry causes rapid tarnishing on contact. Regular wearing actually slows tarnish because the friction of wear acts as gentle polishing.

Can I shower with my handmade ring?

It's best not to. Soap builds up in settings and dulls stones over time. Hot water can loosen adhesive-set stones and cause thermal expansion that stresses metal settings. Repeated water exposure accelerates tarnish on silver. The risk per shower is small, but the cumulative effect over months and years is significant.

What does 'hypoallergenic' mean for jewelry?

There's no regulated standard for 'hypoallergenic' in jewelry. The most common contact allergen is nickel, which is present in many silver alloys, white gold, and most base metals. If you have a nickel allergy, look for: pure or fine silver (99.9%), argentium silver (a nickel-free alloy), solid gold (14K or higher yellow gold typically has minimal nickel), platinum, titanium, or niobium. Ask the maker specifically what alloys they use.

Will wearing my jewelry in the sun damage it?

Some gemstones are light-sensitive. Amethyst, citrine, and rose quartz can fade with prolonged sun exposure. Opals can dehydrate and crack in hot, dry conditions. Pearls can yellow or dry out. Metals are generally fine in sunlight. For everyday wear, normal sun exposure isn't a problem — the concern is about leaving pieces in direct sunlight for extended periods (on a car dashboard, windowsill, etc.).

How do I clean handmade brass or copper jewelry?

Brass and copper naturally develop a dark patina (verdigris on copper) that many makers consider part of the design. If you prefer a bright finish, a paste of lemon juice and baking soda applied with a soft cloth, left for 5 minutes, then rinsed and dried works well. For sealed or lacquered brass/copper, just use a damp cloth — don't use acid or abrasives, which will damage the sealant.

Is the green mark on my skin from copper jewelry harmful?

No. The green discoloration is copper oxide/carbonate — the same compound that gives the Statue of Liberty its green color. It's a natural chemical reaction between copper and your skin chemistry (sweat, lotions). It washes off easily and is harmless. If you find it bothersome, apply a thin layer of clear nail polish to the inside of the piece where it contacts skin, or ask the maker about sealant options.

Last updated 2026-05-28. Care recommendations are based on published guidance from material suppliers, trade organizations, and museum conservation departments. Always follow any specific care instructions provided by your item's maker.